Margaret Thatcher applied her neoliberal ideology to every aspect of society. In education, parents were treated as consumers and offered a choice of where to send their children. The theory goes that making funding follow the pupil, forces schools to compete with each other. Good schools thrive. Bad ones fail. So does parentocracy work?
Informing the choice
To paraphrase Goodhart’s law, as soon as a measure becomes a target someone will find a way to game it. The Times’ Parent Power 2023 (paywall) claims to the be the “definitive guide to helping you make one of life’s most important decisions: how to choose a good school.” However, it transpires this definitive guide, is just a web page ranking schools by their raw GCSE results.
Raw final exam results depend almost entirely on the children schools admit. As observed by leading education researchers, “This seems to confuse some commentators, members of the public and even policy-makers who assume that the good results are largely due to what happens in the school rather than the nature of the children selected.” (Gorard & Siddiqui 2016).
Conflicting interests
When the 1988 Education Reform Act introduced this quasi market only 15% of schools acted as their own admissions authority (West & Pennell, 2003). That has rocketed under the academy program. 84% of secondary schools now determine their own admissions arrangements.
The result of basing a market economy approach on meaningless measures which can be gamed has been entirely predictable. The Guardian‘s Fional Millar collated a list of the 10 most common admissions criteria “and how they are used … and abused”.
One suggestion is school choice is more to do with parents avoiding having their children mix with the ‘wrong sort’ of pupil. Proponents don’t usually make that argument. To the extent that the system provides some nominal degree of choice, the poorest members of society will always end up with whatever more affluent ones don’t want.
Segregation
Allowing schools to manipulate their admissions to exclude certain charactaristics results in a lack of diversity. The 2010 Equality Act would normally prevent any discrimination on the grounds of sex or religion but admissions law permits both.
Selective schools take this one step further by segrating on prior attainment. Numerous studies (Bunting & Mooney (2001), Hausknecht et al (2007)) have shown that tutoring improves the scores but this not affordable by everyone. This adds socioeconimic segregation. Since 2014, grammars have admitted about one fifth the number of disadvantaged children compared to nationally.
The final result is a highly fragmented education system and less choice for parents. This plot shows the breakdown of 270,790 pupils in England’s 11 fully selective areas and the type of school they attend.
(Move the mouse over the graph to see the proportions of children in each category and/or open in new tab.)

Baked beans
A market-based approach can work very well when applied to a suitable product or service. To be effective the consumer needs to
- Make informed purchasing decisions.
- Make frequent (viz. weekly) purchasing decisions.
- Be spending their own money.
This works for baked beans. Consumers know how much they cost. They can tell if they taste like old socks or contain rat droppings. If they consume baked beans this is part of their regular shopping using their own money.
Understanding the quality of a school is any good is lot harder than understanding the quality of baked beans. Schools teach children creativity, social skills, critical thinking, derivative subsumption (linking prior learning in new ways), divergent thinking, collaborative working. These are all key skills for the global digital economy. You won’t see these attributes mentioned in league tables because they can’t be measured. As Cameron observes in Casual Introduction to Sociological Thinking, “Not everything that counts can be counted, and not everything that can be counted counts.” (1963)
GCSEs largely assess acquired knowlege. In the information age, finding information is trivial. Knowing how to apply it is crucial. The Times et al persist with a system of education conceived during the C18th Industrial Revolution to create factory workers. Adding neoliberal parentocracy to the mix at best creates what economists call a positive feedback loop. ‘Good’ schools become more selective about who they admit and end up with better raw exam results. In practice however, this obsession with exam results drives the wrong behaviour in those who have the critical responsibility for educating the next generation.
The data
The plot shows data for the 11 fully selective local authorities taken from the Schools Pupils and Characteristics dataset (2022) published by the Department for Education. (Buckinghamshire, Trafford, Kent, Medway, Southend-on-Sea, Torbay, Wirral, Sutton, Slough, Lincolnshire, Bexley.)
Recent Comments