In February 2022 the First Tier Tribunal (FTT) ruled that the Buckinghamshire Grammar Schools (TBGS) did not need to disclose the reliability of its 11+ tests provided by Granada Learning Assessment (GLA). Last week the Upper Tribunal granted me permission to appeal that decision.

The background

In 2019 the BBC reported that the Verbal Reasoning (VR) section of the Bucks 11+ contained “impossible-to-answer” questions. TBGS and GLA agreed a solution involving removing eight questions from the test.

Parents were concerned about the impact this had on the reliability of the test. TBGS wrote to parents saying, “Detailed statistical analysis has been carried out and the solution proposed to and accepted by TBGS is robust. TBGS is confident that the issue has been resolved in a fair manner for all children and that the results for testing are robust. This outcome has been verified by an independent statistician.” GLA also told parents reliability had not been impacted. One group of parents described the notifications provided by TBGS and GLA as, “… a deliberate act of misdirection.”

The original hearing

I asked TBGS to disclose the analysis they based their decision making on. They refused. This led to the appeal. TBGS told the court that even the number of questions in the test was a “Trade Secret”. They said tutors could use this information to reverse engineer the reliability of the test and use this information to gain unfair advantages for their clients. I argued the reason they didn’t want to disclose the reliability of the test was they didn’t want to disclose the reliability of the test.

The Upper Tribunal’s decision

This week’s ruling says, “it was arguably inadequate for the FTT decision simply to state that it accepted the evidence of TBGS on a matter of which they did not have first-hand knowledge (as tutors) or objective expertise”. Upper Tribunal Judge Citron specifically questioned whether the lower court should have taken at face value witness evidence that disclosure of the number of questions in the test and its reliability would benefit private tutors.

I am profoundly indebted to David Lawson, chair of the Education Law Society for representing me pro-bono. Although the Tribunal system is theoretically open to unrepresented appellants, his involvement was essential in persuading the Upper Tribunal to reverse its earlier decision and grant permission to appeal.

Fun fact

The First Tier Tribunal judge who heard this appeal was the same one whose decision I successfully challenged in 2019.