This paper investigates the hypothesis that if children are intensely tutored to do well in the 11+ this also likely boosts their KS2 SATs results. If pressure is then eased after they entry to selective secondary schools that might manifest itself in lower KS2 to KS4 progress than would otherwise be expected.
There is no data to indicate which individual students are tutored. The study used IDACI (Income Deprivation Affecting Children Index) as a proxy and found a statistically significant relationship between this an progress. More affluent children progress less between KS2 and KS4.
The research was not peer reviewed but Dr Leunig, chief scientific advisor at the DfE drew comparisons with Rodeir Zanini’s observations (2015) that whilst A-level results were good predictors of university degree classifications students from private schools didn’t do quite as well as their A-Level results would suggest. In both scenarios, teaching to the test shows short term gains.
Recommendations
- Control of admissions policies should be moved from schools to independent external bodies to remove the conflict of interests which currently exists
- Given these tests are used to decide the educational futures of
hundreds of thousands of children each year they should be
regulated and standardised - 11+ test results should be included in the National Pupil Database
so they are available to researchers - Proper trials into the effect of tutoring should be commissioned by
the Department for Education - Given these are ‘high stakes’ tests independent research should also
be conducted into other potential prejudices the tests may display
such as towards EAL and dyslexic pupils. - If grammar school admissions were centralised an empirical method
of ‘poverty weighting’ could be introduced but serious consideration
would need to be given to how such a system could avoid being
abused. - The DfE should investigate why one quarter of the IDACI data for
selective school pupils is missing from the autumn 2015 Census
The full paper can be downloaded here.

Citation
Vidal Rodeiro, C., & Zanini, N. (2015). The role of the A* grade at A level as a predictor of university performance in the United Kingdom. Oxford Review of Education, 41(5), 647–670. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/03054985.2015.1090967
Leave a Reply