Equality in Education

Category: Uncategorised (Page 4 of 4)

Local schools for local children

Studies have shown that children who walk or cycle to school concentrate better than those who are transported by car, train, or bus, children attending a local school cuts down on unnecessary travel and we’d like to see all publicly funded schools being at the heart of the community, predominantly providing places to local children.  Addressing the House of Parliament in 2010, the Rt Hon Rob Wilson, MP for Reading East said, “I would like my local grammar schools to re-engage with the task of aiding social mobility for clever, poorer local Reading children rather than being regional schools.”  The 2010 Schools Admissions Code said, “admission arrangements should support sustainable and healthy travel.” although this was removed by the coalition government when the code was revised for 2012.

We are running a petition asking decision makers such as school governing bodies to consider changes to admissions so they revert to being at the heart of the community providing places predominantly for local children.  We’d be interested to  hear about any schools who appear more concerned about selecting those children they want to admit than the wishes of the community in which the schools are situated so we can add them to the decision makers the petition is aimed at.

Further reading

Petitions

References

True league tables

All these reports really tell us is how elitist these schools are over admissions.

Each year the DfE publish 500+ different metrics for all schools.  The mainstream media (Daily Telegraph,The Independent,The BBC,Daily Mirror) take just one measure from this wealth of information, the final GCSE results, and use this as the basis to tell the public which are the ‘best’ secondary schools in the country.  But performance at GCSEs is predominantly a product of performance at KS2 so all these reports really tell us is how elitist these schools are over admissions.

So if final GCSE results doesn’t give any indication of which schools are providing the best return on public money or answer the basic question, ‘what’s best for my child?’ what does?

The DfE also publish Best 8 Value Added which they explain measures, “progress made by pupils from the end of KS2 to the end of KS4 using their best 8 exam results”.  For some reason measures of actual progress which should be of interest to parents and taxpayers alike is largely disregarded by the media.  To demonstrate the point we’ve taken the BBC’s “Secondary league tables” as our starting point and added a progress based ranking for each school.

School ASchool BSchool C(row sums)
#1
Size661433211
#2FSM8.60%21.70%18.00%
#3Dist(km)1.5211.6280.931
#4Size/dist^2285.72163.37243.44692.53
#5weight41.26%23.59%35.15%100.00%
#6wght×FSM3.55%5.12%6.33%14.99%

There were a few surprises in those results so to investigate further we plotted KS2 APS – how well pupils were performing when they entered the school (in blue) against the Total average capped point score per pupil – how well the same pupils went on to do at GCSE (in red).

BBC 'top' 100 schools KS2 plotted against KS4

BBC ‘top’ 100 schools KS2 plotted against KS4

For the most part final GCSE attainment tracks KS2 attainment, confirming that final achievement is predominantly a product of how well the pupils were performing when they entered the school.

The two sharp downward spikes, King Edward VI Camp Hill School for Boys and Dr Challoner’s Grammar School, are worthy of comment. Instead of praising these schools for being in the ‘top 100‘ the press should really be asking them why, after selecting the very brightest pupils in the country they’ve managed to make so little actual progress.  This is all the more so since research carried out by Education Datalab has observed that schools with the most able intakes tend to make the most progress giving them a head start.

The real top performing schools

This next table shows the top 100 schools in the country when this is based on progress instead of just prior attainment.

MeasureDescription
Below 10% quantile
very inclusive
Between 10% and 25% quantilesmore inclusive than most
Between 25% and 75% quantilesbroadly typical
Between 75% and 90% quantilesless inclusive than most
Above 90% quantile.among the least inclusive

The majority (89/100) of the schools demonstrating the best pupil progress are comprehensive although that’s really to be expected since most of the country’s schools are comprehensive.

Our award for the worst misreporting of school performance has to go to the sensationalist Daily Mirror who also reported the ten worst schools in the country.  This included St George’s CofE in Broadstairs.  Over a third of St George’s pupils are on pupil premium and quarter of them arrive as low attainers because the school don’t have the luxury of cherry picking just the bright ones.  The staff and management of that school provide an excellent service to the community and their Value Add exceeds some of those in the BBCs ‘top 100‘ but here they are being branded as being the worst in the country, simply because of the type of children they work with.

No measurement of attainment or progress can ever be perfect but it really is time the press ceased their preoccupation with final attainment and started asking which of our publicly funded schools are providing the best progress to those pupils they teach.

CEM

The University of Durham’s Centre for Evaluation and Monitoring (CEM) tests are being used to decide who gets a place at an increasing number of our state funded grammar schools.  Given the increased importance these tests are playing in the conduct of public affairs we were rather disappointed with CEM’s response to our attempts to find out a little more about them.  In a recent discussion we had with Richard Adams from the Guardian he described CEM as “the good guys” and on the whole we’d agree. They produced the report Evidence on the effects of selective educational systems on behalf of the Sutton Education Trust which is an essential read for anyone with an interest in the subject and do seem to have a genuine desire to make the imperfect process of testing as good as it can be.

We asked CEM for information on the following three topics and feel they still have some way to go with responses on all of these before we’d consider they’re operating in a fully open and transparent manner.

Test results – Standardisation.

When the latest round of test results were published (late October 2014) we were immediately struck by the incredibly wide range of scores, over nine standard deviations! from the mean.  (-4.8, +4.33)σ.

We asked CEM for copies of the raw and standardised results so we could understand for ourselves how they had calculated the final standardised scores. CEM declined to provide this information on the grounds that merely releasing the results of the tests themselves would prejudice their commercial interests. An argument we disagree with and are pursuing.

Possibly thinking that we have a narrow personal agenda, CEM did provide the sort of information that parents of those who sat the tests would be probably be interested in – the birth month, gender, cohort and standardised scores for all those who sat the Slough, Reading, Kendrick tests but far from satisfying our curiosity this only exacerbated it. The released information shows that CEM are doing something rather unique with their standardisation calculations and under such circumstances we’re very concerned that they seem to want to keep this a secret.

Standardised score are worked out using the standard formula:

standardisation formulawhere x is the raw score, μ is the mean score and σ is the standard deviation.

 

Straight away you can see that with μ and σ (the mean and standard deviation) being fixed for the whole cohort who took the test that there can only be the same number of different standardised scores as there are different raw scores.   Normally in 11+ tests each question is given one mark for a correct answer and no marks for a wrong answer. The CEM entrance tests consist of two 50 minute papers containing verbal reasoning, non-verbal reasoning and mathematical questions and we would estimate there are no more than 50 questions in any one category so there should a maximum of about 50 different possible standardised scores (actually 51 as you can also score zero).

The released information for the Kendrick cohort, for example, shows there were 1108 candidates but 1010 different standardised scores. That is only possible if different questions are awarded different amounts. We suspect that they may be weighting each question individually based on it’s difficulty so a question which most candidates correctly answer does not scores as highly as one which only a few get right. Then again they could be disembowelling a monkey and looking at its entrails to decide on the scoring.

We’d really like CEM to provide us the information we requested so we can make our own informed decision about whether it’s a good thing or not. Damaging commercial interests? The information they released is in the pubic domain. It would take a competitor the same three or four minutes it took us to realise that CEM have moved away from the standard one mark per question approach and about the same length of time to speculate how they’re doing this, although probably not the monkey guts thing but the other one.

Accuracy of the tests

We requested the 95% confidence interval for a score of 110 in the Reading/Kendrick tests and 111 in the Slough tests.  Confidence intervals are just the sort of thing that statisticians get all excited about because they provide an objective measure of the accuracy of what’s being measured. CEM initially said they don’t have this information – rather remarkable for a organisation which specialises in objective research into testing. We explained we were interested in any information they may have relating to the accuracy of the tests.  CEM have replied that if we can specifically request the information they hold then they can provide it but they’ve not told us what information they hold making it impossible to request this information.

We can’t help thinking that CEM do have information relating to the accuracy of the tests but they don’t want to provide it.  We’ve told them that we think their reply does not comply with section 16 of the Freedom of Information Act so we’ll have to see what they come back with.

Level of precision

There are non hard and fast rules about what level of precision should be used for any given measurement although there are clearly some cases where the use of precision is inappropriate.  For example measuring time in milliseconds … with a sundial … on a ship … in a gale.  All other grammar schools measure 11+ test results in whole integers (1/15σ). Assuming this is then taken as a reasonable level of precision there is no rational justification to increase this precision unless accompanied by a proportional increase in accuracy. It was therefore quite a shock when the Reading/Kendrick scores – which are exactly the same accuracy as Slough results – were posted out to one hundred times greater precision.  This is all the more concerning in view of an undertaking given by Reading School to Rob Wilson MP that when they moved to CEM tests they would be guided by CEMs recommendations on scoring.

We’d like to know if Reading School went back on a written undertaking they gave to their local member of parliament or if alternatively, CEM told them that they should record the scores to two decimal places.  CEM declined to shed any light on this question saying that they don’t hold any information about which organisation suggested/recommended this.

Information Security Policy

1. INTRODUCTION

TRAK will be undertaking research, scholarship and learning and is heavily dependent on using information in whatever form and wherever it exists.  Because of its importance, we recognise that this organisation must protect its information assets.  We will do this in ways that are appropriate and cost effective. This will help safeguard adherence to the General Data Protection Regulation 2016/679 and maintain our good reputation for security.

Our ability to exploit and gain advantage from information will enable us to maintain and improve our reputation and ensure that we meet our strategic goals. This policy will therefore support and strengthen the implementation of our Information Strategy.

2. SECURITY OBJECTIVE

Our security objective is to protect TRAK from security problems that might have an adverse impact on our operations and professional standing.

Security problems can include confidentiality (the wrong people obtaining information), integrity (information being altered without permission, whether deliberate or accidental) and availability (information not being available when it is required). The widest possible definition of security will be used to include all types of incident that impact the effective use of information. This includes performance, consistency, reliability, accuracy and timeliness.

3. PRINCIPLES

3.1 Approach

We will use the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) Guidelines for the Security of Information Systems and Networks, Towards a Culture of Security upon which BS7799, Code of Practice for Information Security Management are based as a framework for guiding our approach to managing security.

We will use all reasonable, appropriate, practical and effective security measures to protect our important processes and assets in order to achieve our security objectives.

We will continually examine ways in which we can improve our use of security measures to protect and enhance our business.

As a responsible organisation, TRAK will protect and manage our information assets to enable us to meet our contractual, legislative, privacy and ethical responsibilities.

As a centre of research and scholarship, we will ensure that our data are held safely so that their continued validity is not questioned.

3.2 Responsibilities

Everyone within TRAK or who uses our information will be responsible for protecting our information assets, systems and infrastructure. They will, at all times, act in a responsible, professional and security-aware way, according to the principles in this Policy.

Everyone will protect information assets that are entrusted to them, whether such protection is required contractually, legally, ethically or just out of respect for other individuals or organisations.

We recognise the right to academic and individual freedom, but freedom also requires responsibilities. An individual may not put the intellectual and information assets of others at risk through carelessness or selfishness.

All those associated with TRAK are responsible for identifying security shortfalls in our existing practices and/or improvements that could be made.

All members of TRAK expected actively to coach and encourage best practice amongst colleagues.

The chief information office (CIO) is responsible and accountable for ensuring that our security objective is achieved.

The CIO is responsible for allocating sufficient resources to allow TRAK to realistically achieve its security objectives. This includes people, time, equipment, software, education and access to external sources of information and knowledge.

Any breaches, or suspected breaches of the GDPR will be reported to the Information Commissioner whether caused by members of TRAK or other external organisations.  Any remedies suggested by the Commissioner should be implemented immediately (if not already actioned).

3.3 Practices

Using risk analysis techniques, we will identify our security risks and their relative priorities, responding to them promptly and confidently, implementing safeguards that are appropriate, effective, culturally acceptable and practical.

To promote better sharing and exploitation of information, all members of TRAK will have free access to internal information, including details of security measures employed, unless there is a clear need to restrict their access eg where restricted data has been provided by an organisation such as the National Pupil Database.

All members of TRAK will be accountable for their actions and all actions will be attributable to an identified individual through use of password protected accounts on the organisation website.

All information (including third party information) will be protected by safeguards and handling rules appropriate to its sensitivity and criticality.

Information held by TRAK will only be disclosed to third parties when their need to know it has been consciously assessed and with clear undertakings on its subsequent use. Information owners will be responsible for identifying to whom their information may be released and on what terms. Research and scholarship information has important intellectual property rights; disclosure of personal information is subject to law.

 

TRAK will ensure that actual or suspected security incidents relating to ICT systems will be reported promptly to the CIO who will ensure that the incident is managed to closure, and analyse it for lessons to be learnt. Documented Procedures and Standards, education and training, will supplement these Principles.

Compliance with the Policy will be monitored on a regular basis by Internal Audit.

3.4 Security Policy Review

The CIO owns this Policy and is committed to the implementation of it. He will facilitate an annual review of it by the Business Strategy Group. The policy will be reviewed for completeness, effectiveness and usability. Effectiveness will be measured by TRAK’s ability to avoid security incidents and minimise resulting impacts, together with a process for benchmarking security maturity with other similar establishments.

3.5 Policy Awareness

The CIO will send an electronic copy of this policy to each new member joining TRAK and keep the current edition readily available on the TRAK’s Intranet server. Following each review, the online document will be updated and copies sent to all members.

3.6 Applicability and Enforcement

This Policy applies to all members of TRAK who administer the website.

Failure to comply with the Security Policy could damage the image of TRAK.

Last updated 21 April 2018 to reflect change in UK legislation (GDPR)

Newer posts »

© 2026 TRAK

Theme by Anders Norén — Up ↑

Creative Commons License
Except where otherwise noted, the content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.